Thursday, June 11, 2009

Science without religion is lame, religion without science is blind.

In the interest of my well - known stand on gender equality,the usage of the male gender (for matters divine and mortal) in this post is for the sake of convenience only. Please substitute the same with Mitochondrial Eve as and when required.

Feynmann once remarked, "God is needed for understanding those things which you don't believe the laws will explain, such as consciousness, or why you only live for a certain length of time — life and death — stuff like that. God is always associated with those things that you do not understand."

Why did humanity require God and religion in the first place?
For prehistoric man, the world around him was shrouded in mystery. The elemental forces of nature that were necessary for human sustenance could suddenly strike back without warning leaving a trail of death and destruction in their wake. The same fire that helped Man to cook his food and keep himself warm could rage through a forest and leave men burnt. The rain that nourished his crops could pour down in torrents washing away his hard work. The river where he washed the grime off his body or fur/hide could swell angrily past its banks in a flood and wash away all that he held dear. The gentle breeze , a breath of relief after a hard day's night could just as unexpectedly turn into a cyclone or a dust storm that blew him away. (All puns intended)
With his primitive science, the vagaries of Mother Nature were far beyond the comprehenion of poor ol' Y - Chromosomal Adam. Perhaps it gave him comfort to believe in an omnipresent, omniscient being who watched over the Universe.... to quote the old chestnut, "God has to exist, for if he doesn’t, we’re in trouble".
Religion with naturalistic motifs may have been born in the confused aftermath of tragedies - explaining natural disasters or illness as the rage of an angry God who could be appeased by ceremonies or sacrifices. Death and destruction were borne with greater courage and grace if one believed in a heavenly afterlife. Trials and tribulations were mitigated by faith in a divine presence who was certain to make sure that "All's well that ends well".
Rituals, by virtue of their repetitiveness and normalcy would be therapeutic for humans, giving them something to focus on instead of their worry / pain. Also, they seem to give humanity the faith (though some call it wishful thinking) that they can shape the highs and lows of destiny to their liking.

Is religion in our genes?
From Matt Ridley's book, "Nature via Nurture: Genes, Experience and What Makes Us Human":
In a recent study [psychologist Thomas] Bouchard measured how [religiously] fundamentalist individuals are by giving them questionnaires about their beliefs. The correlation between the resulting scores for identical twins reared apart is 62 percent; for fraternal twins reared apart it is just 2 percent. Bourchard repeats the exercise with a different questionnaire designed to elicit a broader measure of religiosity and still gets a strong result: 58 percent [for identical twins reared apart] vs 27 percent [for fraternal twins reared apart].

Religion conferred an evolutionary (and hence genetic) advantage on the primitive Homo Sapien. Being communal in nature, it fostered a cohesive bond amongst a group of hunter gatherers. This engendered a greater sense of togetherness , producing a lean, mean survival machine, a group that worked together towards common goals whether it be defending their territory or hunting down prey. Such a force would bring in more food -----> Full bellies ------> Increased physical and mental strength -----> Greater immunity to diesease -----> Healthier offspring ; a virtuous circle of sorts.
The more capable religion was of producing a group streamlined for survival, the greater was the group members' chance of passing on their genes to subsequent generation. Hence, religions that endured were those that had stood the test of time (and evolution) and passed with flying colours.

Why are God and religion a bone of contention between the atheists and theists?
Through the centuries, we have discovered the reasons for the natural phenomena that so plagued early man. This doesn't contradict religion, but it does takes away one of the original motivations for religion.

This does not mean that a lack of belief in the Divine precludes the belief in humanity/ moral values. But if all scientists had believed that the natural phenomena existed because God made them, science would never have progressed.
A scientist has to question the dogma of the past, that is how new theories come into existence. In any experiment/ new theory, the burden of proof is omnipresent. These beliefs (from what I've read) tend to spill over into other fields, one of which is the existence of God. There is no absolute proof that God exists, hence skepticism creeps in.
To justify this dogma, Kant in his Critique Of Reason, says God is in the noumenal realm where we have no intuition or direct experience of Him. I guess that means we take our belief in God, on faith (literally and figuratively) since we can't perceive him through the normal five senses.

However, the truth of the matter as far as those who swear by absolute proof are concerned :
- Science has failed to find natural evidence of God. For men of science, natural evidence is all there is. No God. Case closed.
- Slightly softer is this line of reasoning: Science erases the "need" for God as an explanation of our experiences, and God either doesn't exist or is at best a hypothesis (to the agnostic).

Despite this, many famous scientists still held on to the belief in the Divine:
I believe in Spinoza's God who reveals himself in the orderly harmony of what exists, not in a God who concerns himself with the fates and actions of human beings ~Albert Einstein

Numero pondere et mensura Deus omnia condidit
God created everything by number, weight and measure. ~Isaac Newton

At bottom God is nothing more than an exalted father. ~ Sigmund Freud

I do not feel obliged to believe that the same God who has endowed us with sense, reason, and intellect has intended us to forgo their use. ~Galileo Galilei


Perhaps religion endures because of its humanity (I mean both humankind as a species and the more emotional meaning of the word). As far as science is concerned, humankind is the most evolved in a series of serendipitious mutations since the first group of appropriately combined hydrocarbons spawned life ; we are but well seasoned derivatives of the primordial soup. It does not deal with messy emotions or life's major questions. It deals with life, not living.
Religion, on the other hand, perhaps because it is of the people, by the people and for the people, essentially revolves around humanity. It helps us cope with tragedies, what to do when we're in a moral dilemma, it helps us in the realities of our day to day life and restrains us from running pell mell towards the greener grass on the other side.

Hence, the title quote, courtesy Herr Einstein. Science only tells us what we can do, religion tells us what we ought to do. However, science enables us to weed out the fantastic stories that pepper all religions' scriptures and focus on the tenets that will guide our ascent to a more evolved plane of thinking, leaving the pettiness behind.

The belief in God, a benevolent all - encompassing, loving entity often brings out the best in men. Perhaps the faith that though certain decisions / happenstances are beyond our capability, they will be taken care of by a Higher Power helps us relax and let go of the burden of stress we take on. In a frame of mind, unclouded by fear, our natural abilities and instincts come to the fore, enabling us to take the optimum decision for the situation.


It is my belief that faith is a purely personal matter, which will persist regardless of arguments for and against it. The personification of God, whether known as Avatar or Messiah, is required because humans in their frailty identify best with the divinity if portrayed in a human form.

However, inspite of the fact that all religions preach the same basic values, a few people insist on condemning others faiths needlessly. On further reflection, I surmise that people who try to pull down another's faith are doing so in an effort to hide from the lacunae they perceive in their own beliefs. In an effort to drown out that niggling inner voice, they overcompensate by shouting their derogatory remarks from the rooftops, hoping for validation from the multitude.

I feel that if your religion (or moral code sans the so - called opium of the masses) provides succour during times of sorrow and pain and keeps you grounded in times of plenty, then it has fulfilled its purpose.
To make it more personal , I've observed that medicos often need to fall back on faith in God and religion. At times a patient beyond the pale of hope makes a miraculous recovery for reasons we cannot explain, 'tis a time that makes you believe that there must be a God, and thank the heavens for that. Sometimes, we do all we can for our patients, but the awareness is still there that their life is not in our hands. It is so much more heartbreaking if he/she is a young child or the sole breadwinner. At such times, a belief in a benevolent higher power helps one to soldier on, to give our best and hope that all will work out or gives one the strength to deal with (those inevitable) failures.

Man does not live by bread alone. We need religion to ground us, to help us navigate our way through the agony and the ecstasy of life. We require it to come to terms with our mortality. We reflect on the Divine idea to rise above the trivialties of everyday existence. However, the belief in God (or humanity, in its abstract form) is most important in that it propels us down the path of knowledge towards perfection ; it inspires us to strive towards an ideal... Nirvana.

Doctor Witch
Doctor Witch

Tuesday, November 4, 2008

Nothing's Gonna Change My Love For You...

A crystal - clear childhood memory (I was about 9 years old) is of this song playing at 11:00 pm and watching my parents waltz (or was it just simply sway?) to Glenn Madeiros' crooning.

Watching my parents laugh together, grieve together, work together and (last but definitely not the least) fight together has been, to say the least, an educational experience.

My mother subscribes to the view (lifted from Everybody Loves Raymond) that every marriage must have room for hate. And God knows that when they're arguing the vituperation they spew sometimes looks exactly like that.
Of course, being secure that they're meant to be together, I've spent a good part of growing up holding on to my sides while I laughed my head off (and to tell the truth, even adding fuel to the fire for my entertainment)at their fights and their agreements.

That being said, the tiny gestures they make for each other are nonpareil.
-Dad floored Mom with a delivery of 24 long-stemmed, red roses on the day of their jadhakamkhoda (engagement)
-Mom is rather shy so Dad dared her to hold his hand on the kalyanamandapam. So, the photos of the exchange of rings has everyone laughing, for she neatly tricked him and floored him by holding his hand then. Family lore says he was mumbling "That's not fair" with a wide grin on his face. Apparently, the terms included the loser serve tea in bed to the winner the morning after. I wonder what my paternal grandparents had to say to that !!!
-Dad will call up everyday just to hear her voice (and if one of them is out of town, the tempo is stepped up to an embarassing 5 calls a day, at least).
-Mom will not eat her dinner till he comes home (and during season time, that is sometimes 2:00 am).

Ah, I could go on, but some of the instances which are important to me might seem mundane to an impartial observer. These priceless memories wove the tapestry of a happy and cherished childhood ; they are my true inheritance.

It has been said that "An anniversary is a time to celebrate the joys of today, the memories of yesterday, and the hopes of tomorrow."
Twenty seven years and counting... I wonder how they manage it. One person for the rest of your life, it sounds warm and fuzzy and yet kinda scary at the same time.


With God's grace, may silver turn to gold and diamond, Dad and Mom.
Happy Anniversary. I love you two beyond measure.


Doctor Witch

Saturday, September 27, 2008

How Green Was My Valley...

Every now and then, a bunch of pretty, rosy - cheeked women go door to door asking for food, old clothes or money, whatever you can spare. Further investigation reveals that they are the much talked of, displaced Kashmiri Pundits, who fled the Valley and have been living in refugee camps for years. They talk wistfully of their homeland with its verdant, green valleys, beautiful meadows carpeted with flowers and fruit trees bowed down with produce. Crystal clear are those memories but sadly that is all they remain, reminiscences of a better time with no intention to bring it back to life. In fact a new generation of Kashmiris have been born in the camps, youngsters who will never see the Valley but will grow up yearning for it. They're like young animals in captivity, staring out through the bars, hearing about freedom from past generations, but never quite figuring out what it is.

Their resigned acceptance of their lot has always struck me as odd, in fact it angers me. I’ve always felt that they were giving up without a fight. Nothing comes easy ; and it would be especially difficult to reclaim a fertile land, a cash cow for nations, a vantage point for the various wars over the past sixty years. Sitting back and wallowing in the memories of the past only means that one does not create new experiences for the morrow.

After all, Article 370 does allow the natives to resettle in Kashmir even if the rest of India can not. Yes, you might call that a simplistic view ; there will be pain and suffering, but the axiom "No pain, no gain" was coined to illustrate exactly that scenario. The pilgrims will , of course, suffer (as path breakers often do). Great numbers may even die, but from their ashes will rise intrepid explorers, descendants that will build on the legacy of their ancestors and take the new world from height to height. In fact, one has to admire the men and women who landed in the untamed Americas for their guts and forbearance in the face of tremendous tribulations. It is the temerity and pioneering spirit of these men and women that set the foundations for the USA as the superpower it is today.

"Arise ô Kashmiris, remember that a nation requires warriors, to defend knowledge, to protect one's women and children, to guard one's borders from the enemy…", regain the land of your forefathers.

The Kashmiris, however, are busy bemoaning the fact that they’ve been displaced from their homeland, looking back at the past than forward to the future ; one does not see them chalking out a gameplan or even bringing their plight to the notice of the powers-that-be. Unfortunately, when you try to explain this state of affairs to them, though they nod and agree, you can see it in their eyes that they aren’t really taking it in ; they seem to have got so used to an easy life of taking charity and aid that even if it was handed to them on a platter, I wonder if they would measure up to the turmoil and hardship of rebuilding their lives in a land reeling from the aftermath of insurgency.

Throughout history, we’ve seen many displaced cultures ; some of them regain their land while others become minorities in their own home base.
The American Indians are a classic example ; a thriving civilization that got marginalized by invaders with guns, now reduced to living in reservations in a land of immigrants. One might compare them to the Indians (of South- East Asia), attacked by the same gun-toting marauders who entered in the guise of merchants. They even got lazy/ cowered for a couple of centuries (with the exception of a few incidents like the Revolt of 1857) but finally the people reached breaking point. A nation was formed from the plundered ruins, and it arose with one voice to claim its lost birthright and regain its tarnished pride.
The common thread I've observed in those who get their nations back is the determination they have and their unwavering focus on their aim. The Tibetans, for one, may not have got back their land ; but they do make their voices heard whether through the denizens of Hollywood (who seek the Dalai Lama's blessings) or during the Beijing Olympics.

Another fine example are the Jews who managed to carve out their own little bit of home from a territory that was openly hostile to them. Whether by hook or by crook, by sheer brute force or the support of the West (thanks to some prominent bankers from the community, for as we know money talks), they realized their ideal : their Promised Land. Just as importantly, they’ve hung on to their dream (over the past 60 years), through all adversities and still give their beloved neighbours one heck of a run for their money.

My viewpoint on this issue : Faint heart never won fair lady doesn’t just apply to human relationships, it has its role on the global stage. (Yes, clichés were invented because some situations just keep repeating themselves :P).


If you've set your heart on a certain aim , you must fight for it, give it your all, no holds barred, pursue your cause with a single - minded zeal . You don’t just sit around railing at fate for handing you such a rotten deal, for then all that happens is that a more worthy crusader, one who has more passion for the cause, walks off with both the laurels and the prize.

Thursday, August 28, 2008

Books on the to-read list

Zen and the Art Of Motorcycle Maintenance - Robert M. Pirsig
Foucault's Pendulum - Umberto Eco.
I've lost count of the number of people who've recommended those books.

The Eye Of The World - Robert Jordan.
The Wheel Of Time.
Sakshi, if this doesn't work out, we have a clash of the scalpels.

Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman!: Adventures of a Curious Character - Richard Feynman.
This, I know, will be good.

Weed - Paro Anand .
An interesting perspective on the jihadi situation - through the eyes of a child.
And to be honest, I found the author's name kinda cool too. :D

You've gotta love Crossword sales, three hours of paradise.
SIGH
Why can't I spend the rest of my life there?

Doctor Witch

Sunday, July 27, 2008

Courage Brother, Do Not Stumble...

That is my School Hymn and a source of inspiration at any time.

When it seems like nothing's working out, just put one step in front of the other, just keep on walking... after all the darkest hour is always just before dawn.

Doctor Witch

Friday, May 23, 2008

The Pupil Becomes The Teacher...

Yesterday, I taught my first teacher - my mother- the art of blood collection.

The guinea pig - Me , of course.

She managed, like a dream. Some things, I guess are in the genes.

Doctor Witch

Tuesday, May 6, 2008

Summertime Blues!!!

That song's kinda stuck in my head. But it fits my mood perfectly.

Sinusitis, a chalazion and epistaxis all in one week, that's one heck of a track record. It's like the Universe doesn't want me to study.(Yes, I'm so good at coming up with lame excuses, I could pass off as a guy in that particular field)

Doctor Witch